Dealership found metal chunks in rear end just before Oregon trip

[Ducati1098]

Well, at the risk of being accused of having watched to many police procedurals, as several have pointed out in this thread there is a question(s) of what exactly what it is we are looking at, how it got there (and what "there" exactly is). Since it is the rear diff why not just pull the cover and confirm (assuming this has not already been done)? I personally would have minimally ask for that.

As far was work being done that is not necessary, I am sure it happens all the time, usually by mistake or lack of thoroughness of course. Heck, think all the manual transmissions that have been replaced under warranty and in vain because of the 'Getrag Rattle'.

My dayjob is managing a medical practice, and in this domain unnecessary work is done all the time, not least because there are all sorts of dysfunctional $incentives$ in the system to encourage it. Now the human body is not a machine, and for it in most cases it defiantly is not better off than it was before this unnecessary work...but I get this a limited analogy.

In any case, I side with those who, at least given the evidence as presented, do not find this situation quite as black and white.

I'm arguing that since the OP took the time to post his story here and presumably wants to learn something, perhaps he ought to have followed up a bit more closely. However I do admit that it is more likely then not that his Bronco will be as good as it was before so he will just be out his time/hassle, so 'all's well that ends well'

That didn’t answer any of my questions lol but that’s okay.
I think the OP is clearly fine with simply having the broken part fixed and getting the Bronco back. So the what, why, when and how doesn’t really matter in the end.

Sponsored

 

[userdude]

Why does it need to be clear though? Whatever caused it is being replaced. You seeing the damage better isn’t going to change the outcome of it being repaired is it?

So you’d rather not have the work done and just leave it damaged if you don’t see more than the picture they sent? That doesn’t seem to be logical.
They aren’t going to randomly recommend warranty work if it wasn’t necessary.

They were of course, jumping kerbs on the grassy knoll and Hoffa was driving with Elvis the wrong seat driver. C'mon! lol

 

[projectbadlands]

I dunno why we need to make this into a conspiracy theory. Maybe it's a fill plug not a drain plug and someone just misspoke somewhere in the game of telephone. The internet is full of horror stories but I'm going to go with innocent until proven guilty.

And its because of these horror stories why we are asking so many questions. A lot of why's at such low mileage.

 

[dgorsett]

Immense respect to @Ducati1098. @flip and all the other dealer associated contributors on this forum. They are nothing short of amazing to give so freely of they're expertise.

However, some of us have had less than stellar performance from automotive repair professionals. I have had instances of nothing short of fraudulent interactions with some. A independent shop that tried to get me to replace a timing chain on aa Ford 300-6 which has no chain (just needed timed) and a dealer that tried to get me to replace a clutch when the linkage just needed a spot of grease. So until I know the technician I approach every interaction with caution.

To the OP: If that plug actually came out of the diff with that chunk on it he might as well let them replace it.

 

[ADM]

Around 2 weeks ago I took my Bronco (2023 base manual 2dr) in for its 30,000 mile service, which is the first major service where they do more than change the oil and top up the washer fluid. It had been driving great and not making any noise, so I was surprised when later that afternoon I got a call from the advisor saying they found "metal flakes" or "shavings" (I forget his exact wording) on the rear diff drain plug. I haven't seen the damage with my own eyes so I don't know how bad it is. A cursory look online suggests that fine powdery shavings is normal wear, but any larger chunks are bad news. He recommended replacing it while the vehicle was still under warranty to save me 3-4 grand. Unfortunately the parts they need have, in his words, "no ETA" so they're just hanging onto my Bronco indefinitely until they can repair it. In the meantime, they've given me a Mustang convertible as a loaner (it was the only other Ford available that day at the local Enterprise, apparently).

If I were only planning to commute during that time, I'd be fine this this arrangement. A bright yellow muscle car isn't really my style, but it does all the car things a car needs to do on the daily drive. However, I'm planning to drive from where I live in the Bay Area up to Oregon this coming Saturday, a trip I've been planning for months and would really not like to cancel. I am expecting to encounter some snow on my route and was counting on having the Bronco's 4WD to get me through if things got hairy. I mean we're not exactly talking Ice Road Truckers here, but better safe than sorry... Only now I'm stuck with a car that has, charitably, a very different set of capabilities.

So, what would you do in this situation? Time is running out to make a decision. Do you think they're right to nip this in the bud while it's still under warranty? Or are they making a bigger deal out of normal wear than they need to, and I should just have them change the fluid as normal and give my Bronco back? If I do have them go through with the repair, will I have any success pestering them to give me a loaner with a skill set closer to the vehicle I actually bought? Any advice is appreciated.

UPDATE so you don't have to hunt through the rest of the thread: What was at first described to me as "metal flakes/shavings" turned out to be big chunks, I don't know exactly what part they broke off of but it definitely wasn't an overreaction to stop driving the Bronco and let them replace the rear end under warranty. Have a look for yourself.

As of writing they will apparently have the new rear end assembly in tomorrow (and that's surprising since some people have been waiting months for the same part), but they likely won't finish installing it before I leave. The consensus as far as the loaner seems to be "people still buy Mustangs back east" so I'm just going to put the miles on their car and pick up the Bronco when I get home.

• Ring and pinion gear set — primary failure point; full replacement required, not inspection only

• All differential bearings (carrier bearings, pinion bearings, axle bearings) — metal contamination necessitates replacement of all bearing surfaces
• Differential carrier assembly — to be replaced if any scoring, pitting, or deformation is found
• Rear axle shafts — to be inspected for spline wear or stress damage; replaced if any anomaly is present
• All seals and gaskets within the rear differential assembly — replacement required as part of any proper overhaul
• Differential housing/case — to be inspected for cracks, scoring, or metal contamination embedded in casting
• Driveshaft U-joints and companion flange — inspect for secondary damage from any vibration or imbalance caused by the differential failure
• Complete flush and refill with OEM-specified differential fluid after all component replacement is complete
• A complete written diagnosis report documenting all components inspected, all components replaced, and all part numbers used — to be provided to me upon completion
• Confirmation that Ford Motor Company warranty authorization has been obtained prior to reassembly
• Road test and post-repair inspection documentation before vehicle return
• Any applicable Technical Service Bulletins (TSBs) related to the Bronco rear differential or MT88 drivetrain to be reviewed and addressed as part of this repair

I want to be a cooperative and reasonable customer throughout this process, and I genuinely appreciate the professionalism your service department has shown thus far. However, I want to be equally clear that I expect Ford to stand behind this vehicle with a repair that fully restores it to factory specification — not a partial fix that leaves degraded components in place that will fail again outside the warranty window.
Please contact me directly to discuss the diagnosis findings and the scope of repair before proceeding with reassembly. I am available by phone and email and will respond promptly.


Sincerely,

A. David Marne



Owner — 2024 Ford Bronco Heritage Edition

Sponsored