These are the 3 concepts I envision for a possible swap. Without being a mechatronics expert myself, I cant say that all are equally possible.
Option A:
Pros: Leaving the OEM PCM may prove easier to integrate all the OE cluster diagnoses and relationships. The PCM and TCM can stay paired and happy, so long as the Donor Motor is doing its job, and key signals are shared (translated) like engine RPM, fuel consumption, throttle input etc.
Cons: Without knowing better, it may still require the same or similar amount of custom SW to operate as option B. Also more cluttered/messy.
Option B:
Pros: cleaner set up than option A. If the translator can be set up to facilitate "direct" connection between the Donor PCM and vehicle, it may be easier to integrate and tune. I think this is how professional shops would attempt a swap if it were possible at all.
Cons: not clear if a translator could be made to satisfy all vehicle signal inputs/outputs.
Option C:
Pros: Less hardware than options A and B, everything handled via SW integration
Cons: Requires either OEM SW support, or a donor motor with aftermarket PCM with the ability to accept custom calibration. Limited Donor motor options with custom PCM (can really only think of Banks Power)
Option A:
Pros: Leaving the OEM PCM may prove easier to integrate all the OE cluster diagnoses and relationships. The PCM and TCM can stay paired and happy, so long as the Donor Motor is doing its job, and key signals are shared (translated) like engine RPM, fuel consumption, throttle input etc.
Cons: Without knowing better, it may still require the same or similar amount of custom SW to operate as option B. Also more cluttered/messy.
Option B:
Pros: cleaner set up than option A. If the translator can be set up to facilitate "direct" connection between the Donor PCM and vehicle, it may be easier to integrate and tune. I think this is how professional shops would attempt a swap if it were possible at all.
Cons: not clear if a translator could be made to satisfy all vehicle signal inputs/outputs.
Option C:
Pros: Less hardware than options A and B, everything handled via SW integration
Cons: Requires either OEM SW support, or a donor motor with aftermarket PCM with the ability to accept custom calibration. Limited Donor motor options with custom PCM (can really only think of Banks Power)
Show full message↓