I have the $25 TD mesh bimini. First installed last Friday and ran all weekend great.
Sponsored
I love the mesh. You still get enough light to feel 'open' but without baking in the sun at stoplights.
Supposedly it can stay on with the hardtop, but I didn't like it. I wasn't entirely sure what to do about the crossbar that uses the same bolting locations, and I didn't like how it sagged when in the 'stowed' position. The zippers aren't in quite the right position to reach the hardtop handles, either.
Nail in the coffin was that it made it almost impossible to get my ratchet straps through for the hardtop hoist, but that's outside the intended design.
I'm fine taking the mesh top off when the hardtop goes back on.